No present for 49ers QB of the future

So the 49ers quarterback of the future isn’t even going to have a present, and if the Faithful — as the fan base has been labeled — is distressed, how do you think the boys in the front office feel?

We’re raised on adages: You’re always one play from being a star. Or being hurt. It’s the nature of football, where one’s best plans might end up on the injured list.

It’s been two and a half years since the Niners traded three first-round picks in the 2021 NFL draft for the third overall choice. That pick would be used to choose an unfamiliar kid from North Dakota State, who we were advised had great potential.

What Trey Lance didn’t have in the few times he was on the field was the good fortune to avoid injury.

That’s the way it works in sport sometimes. Call it kismet. Call it physiology. 

After relying on good old Jimmy Garoppolo (who himself was always getting hurt) Niner management called on Sam Darnold, who was most recently cut by the New York Jets.

You know the story up to here. The boys in the Niner front office (mostly head coach Kyle Shanahan and GM John Lynch), after watching all or part of two preseason games decided that as of now, Lance wasn’t what they needed.

Unmentioned to this point is the savior from nowhere, who was the last pick in the 2022 draft, Brock Purdy, and while we blinked and gasped — and then applauded — quarterbacked the 49ers to the playoffs.

And, of course, he got injured and underwent elbow surgery.

Which is why substitutes are invaluable. Particularly at quarterback, who after numerous practices and two exhibition games turns out to be Sam Darnold. He too, as Trey Lance, was the third overall pick, in the 2018 draft.

He played for the Jets, threw beautifully, and ran effectively but there were problems with his play calling. 

Hey, he was a rookie so what do you expect?

Time and place — and health — always must be part of the package. A man who struggles on one team, in one system, may succeed on another squad with different teammates.

The speculation is the 49ers will try to trade Lance, if only to be somewhat compensated for all those No. 1s they traded to acquire him. Also perhaps to escape being reminded of what they didn’t get.

Patience is a rare commodity in pro sports. The owner, as the fans, wants to win immediately and is often forced to go with players who are ill-prepared. Newspapers and TV stations forever remind the public which coaches are on a figurative hot seat.

You receive plenty of attention in pro football.

What you never get is sympathy. When someone goes down, the cry is “Next man up.” Who in this case is Sam Darnold. As opposed to Trey Lance.

Niners' Shanahan: ‘Didn’t enjoy game by any means’

“It’s not all about the quarterback,” said Greg Papa, who after his years previously as the Raiders announcer and now the 49ers announcer, well knows, that it is indeed always about the quarterback, especially in San Francisco.

Where from Frankie Albert to John Brodie through Joe Montana and Steve Young, it’s been about the man who takes the snaps and the criticism. As was the case Sunday when the Niners played their first preseason (exhibition) game of 2023 to find a backup for Brock Purdy, who as promised pre-game, didn’t play a down Sunday against the Raiders in Las Vegas (sadly now the home of the Oakland Raiders as it seemingly will be of the Oakland Athletics as well).

If you care about the score, that’s your problem. 

The Raiders won, 34-7, and although the result means little in the grand scheme of things, Niners coach Kyle Shanahan said, “I didn’t enjoy the game by any means.”

Not that there wasn’t some value for Shanahan and the Niners, who now understand (as if they didn’t before) the importance of the quarterback, primarily Trey Lance, to unload the ball before the D-line unloads on him.

As a point of information, the late John Madden, when he coached the Raiders, said if a preseason game was one-sided, he wanted to be the loser, the better to get his team’s attention in practice. 

Lance, who started, was sacked four times for 18 yards, the main reason the Niners didn’t get a first down until the second quarter.

“Trey held the ball too long,” affirmed Shanahan. Perhaps because even if he was the No. 3 overall pick in the 2021 draft, he’s barely played, losing the position because of injuries, which enabled first Jimmy Garoppolo, then Purdy to take over.

During the off-season, the Niners signed another first-round QB, Sam Darnold, who as Lance, was a third overall pick by the Jets who kept him until he was booed out of New York, not unusual for any Jets quarterback not named Joe Namath.

Darnold played the second half and after completing his first four pass attempts, finished 5 of 8. He wasn’t sacked once, but situations and lineups change later in play. It also may change after a few weeks and before the regular season begins. 

Is this the way the Niners view their QBs? Will the rotation be Purdy, Lance, and Darnold? Or will Lance or Darnold be waived or traded? And since he’s returning from that season-closing elbow injury, will Purdy be healthy enough to regain his place?

“We’re always hard on quarterbacks,” reminded Shanahan. 

Then, when it appeared he would gripe about what had happened — or considering the lack of offense, what hadn’t — Shanahan softened his attitude. Lance was being protected, in a manner by an O-line lacking numerous starters.

He paid the price for backups playing their roles. Then again, he paid the price of a sub not being completely comfortable with moving up to the level demanded.

It’s not all about the quarterback until it has to be.

And so the Trey Lance era has arrived for the Niners

The heralded Trey Lance era apparently has arrived. Anybody want to search for it among the frustration and disappointment of his first game as the 49ers’ designated savior?

What happened on Sunday was not entirely his fault, San Francisco squandering a 10-0 lead and getting stunned by the Chicago Bears, 19-10.

The defense became defenseless, and the Niners were called for 12 penalties, a number unacceptable for any team not named the Raiders. But the judgment of a QB is made from the final score.

Did he bring his team home a winner, in this game played in an occasional downpour and on a constantly sloppy surface at Soldier Field in Chicago? Lance did not.

The Niners had become the fashionable choice to make the Super Bowl, from all those folks at ESPN to hyper-critical Boomer Esiason. But when the curtain went up, they looked, well, terrible wouldn’t be an inappropriate description.

Kyle Shanahan, the Niners coach, tossed out phrases such as “stupid penalties” and “silly mistakes,” not needing to wait until the videos to tell us what he really thought.

The Niners and Lance, the quarterback who was the third overall pick in the 2021 draft, are hot stuff and the game was shown in many locations.

And while it’s only one game among the 17 on every NFL team’s season schedule, and while even the Super Bowl champ Los Angeles Rams were defeated in their opener, this wasn’t exactly the way to make an impression — for Lance or for the franchise.

“We all know what happened,” said Lance, in his postgame comments, “and we need to fix it.”

What happened was the 49ers had 331 net yards rushing and passing to 204 for the Bears, but botched up everything by holding or doing whatever else that an official would deem against the rules.

The league this season went from four preseason games to three. Perhaps the Niners needed that fourth practice game to learn what was proper and what wasn’t. Or how to fool the refs.

Compared to their dozen penalties for 99 yards, just one short of a football field, the Bears had only three for 24 yards.

“It’s hard enough to play against the opposing team,” left tackle Trent Williams said. “It’s even harder when you play against yourself.”

The Bears were seven-point underdogs in what would be labeled Chicago weather. Early on, they punted five times and quarterback Justin Fields threw an interception. but they won because the 49ers kept screwing up.

“We killed ourselves,” linebacker Fred Warner said. “Every single one of those drives, you can look back and see we did something to help them get in the end zone.”

“We were stopping the run,” said defensive end Nick Bosa, “but we fell apart on penalties.” Asked about Lance, Bosa said, “I was encouraged by the way he played. With that rain, it was hard to throw the ball.”

Shanahan said the field conditions factored into how he used Lance.

“I’ll go back and watch the tape and I’ll ask him how he felt,” Shanahan said. “But it was that type of game.”

Not the type the Niners could have wanted.

Mystery solved for Niners: it’s Trey Lance; is he the right man?

All we wanted to know was who the 49ers would select. Todd McShay of ESPN told us it would be Trey Lance, and Mel Kiper of the same network said it would be Mac Jones. Of course we had to stay tuned, as much to find out who was wrong as to learn who would be the Niners QB after Jimmy G — whenever that inevitability takes place.

But darn if that didn’t take in more time than one of those Super Bowl halftime shows.

The NFL knows how to lure us in and hold on, through country singers, the presentation of the colors and, how appropriate, a Draft Kings commercial.

We know now: Trey Lance.

Sorry, Mr. Kiper. The Niners, who traded three first-round picks for the one they used to take Lance, have to hope they’re not sorry.

Lance played only 17 games at North Dakota State, whose football history doesn’t exactly remind anyone of the schools from which the two players, both quarterbacks, picked ahead of Lance, were taken: No. 1 Trevor Lawrence of Clemson, No. 2 Zach Wilson of BYU.

But Phil Simms went to Morehead State in Kentucky and led the New York Giants to Super Bowl wins.

Joe Montana was a third-round pick and Tom Brady a sixth-round pick, although these days, with changes in the game, a need for more mobile quarterbacks who can escape the rush — as Patrick Mahomes does — top prospects don’t slip that far.

The only thing certain is that Garoppolo, who some predicted would either be traded perhaps to the Patriots, from where the Niners got him, or waived, will be starting the 2021 season as San Francisco’s quarterback. Trey Lance might be the quarterback of the future, but with lack of experience, the future isn’t now.

Mac Jones led Alabama to an undefeated season and a national championship. Yet Niners coach Kyle Shanahan, known as a quarterback specialist, and general manager John Lynch obviously believe in Lance’s potential — and that Garoppolo, who led the team to one Super Bowl, will be more than adequate for a year or two.

Toss Justin Fields of Ohio State into the mix of Niner possible draftees, along with Jones and Lance, until a few days ago, at least, and the impression was that Lance was below the other two.

“I’d be surprised if it’s Trey Lance, unless they decide to go with Jimmy G for another year,” was what NFL Network commentator and former 49er head coach Steve Maricucci told the San Jose Mercury News.

“If they are (keeping Garoppolo, as advertised), any of them could fit. If not, and somebody wants him and grabs Jimmy for a second-round pick, Trey Lance has the most work to do to start in the NFL. Not only did he not play last year (other than one game), he played at another level (FCS) and has the most catching up to do. It would benefit him a lot to sit and watch a veteran guy. All of these quarterbacks would benefit from that.”

You need more than a quarterback — the Chiefs lost in the Super Bowl in February because the offensive line was inadequate. Still, most of all you need a quarterback. He wins the games you should have lost. Lynch and Shanahan decided it was time to acquire that quarterback.

Lance is 6-foot-4 and rushed for 1,100 yards in his lone full season as a starter. He’s known for his football intelligence. And didn’t throw an interception in 287 pass attempts.

“He’s played a year of football (and) it is at a smaller school,” Shanahan said. “So it takes work. You’re not going to see it all. It is a hard process, and that there is no guarantee for any of us. So it’s about believing. You see what they asked him to do. And you see it very consistently done at a high level.”

One mystery is solved. We know the Niners’ next QB. Another remains: Is he the right man?